| Thornton Park Tournament History | |||||||||||
| Year | Championship Game Results | Jerry Masteller MVP Award | Moe Roberts Memorial Award - Most Outstanding Goalie | ||||||||
| 1971 | Padua 6, Garfield Hts. 5 | John Kalnasy, Garfield Heights | |||||||||
| 1972 | Shaker Hts. 4, Garfield Hts. 2 | Dave Straffon, Shaker Heights | |||||||||
| 1973 | Garfield Hts. 3, St. Edward 2 | John Kalnasy, Garfield Heights & | |||||||||
| Max Nelson, Shaker Heights | |||||||||||
| 1974 | Padua 10, Garfield Hts. 3 | Mike Glover, Padua | |||||||||
| 1975 | Bowling Green 6, Padua 4 | Mike Messinger, Bowling Green & | Mark Mazur, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| Doug Hauser, Padua | |||||||||||
| 1976 | Bowling Green 5, Shaker Hts. 2 | Jim Brown, Bowling Green | Mark Mazur, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 1977 | Bowling Green 8, Upper Arlington 4 | Steve Messinger, Bowling Green | Mike Lagabilth, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 1978 | Shaker Hts. 8, Padua 4 | Keith Abood, Shaker Heights | Scott Hicks, Shaker Heights | ||||||||
| 1979 | Bowling Green 8, Bay 2 | Carl Kale & Rick Wright, Bowling Green | Jeff Boutelle, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 1980 | Shaker Hts. 7, Kent Roosevelt 5 | Mark Spring, Shaker Heights | Chris Prisby, Kent Roosevelt & Scott Whipper, Shaker Heights | ||||||||
| 1981 | Bowling Green 5, Shaker Hts. 4 | Bob Schoeni, Bowling Green | Gordon McCance, Euclid | ||||||||
| 1982 | Bowling Green 7, Padua 4 | Chris White, Bowling Green | Gary Hull, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 1983 | Bowling Green 8, Shaker Hts. 2 | Tom Shirkey, Bowling Green | Todd Wright, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 1984 | North Olmsted 6, University School 3 | Rob Petre, North Olmsted | Dave Martin, North Olmsted | ||||||||
| 1985 | Cleveland Hts. 6, North Olmsted 5 (ot) | Rob Petre & Jason Pastore, North Olmsted | Greg Nowak, ,Cleveland Heights | ||||||||
| 1986 | Cleveland Hts. 5, North Olmsted 0 | Pat Ganley, Cleveland Heights | Adam Friedman, Cleveland Heights | ||||||||
| 1987 | Padua 5, Trinity 0 | Brian Wallace, Padua | Jason Perdion, Padua | ||||||||
| 1988 | Padua 5, North Olmsted 4 | Brett Hofstrom, Padua | Mel Leeb, North Olmsted | ||||||||
| 1989 | University School 4, Shaker Hts. 0 | Bunk McMahon, University School | Bunk McMahon, University School | ||||||||
| 1990 | Padua 7, Shaker Hts. 4 | Dan DiMarco, Padua | Bunk McMahon, University School | ||||||||
| 1991 | Padua 7, Cleveland Hts. 2 | Ron Czech, Padua | Rob Schuette, Padua | ||||||||
| 1992 | Shaker Hts. 6, St. Edward 3 | Scott Frerichs, Shaker Heights | Chris Brown, Shaker Heights | ||||||||
| 1993 | St. Edward 3, Shaker Hts. 1 | Jason Dickey, St. Edward | Matt Webster, Shaker Heights | ||||||||
| 1994 | Shaker Hts. 2, Padua 1 | Ben Simon & Ben Friedell, Shaker Heights | Ben Friedell, Shaker Heights | ||||||||
| 1995 | Padua 8, St. Ignatius 1 | Todd Ekstrand, Padua | Jim Kish, Padua | ||||||||
| 1996 | Padua 3, St. Ignatius 0 | R.J. Schoger, Padua | Billy Ferkol, Padua | ||||||||
| 1997 | St. Edward 6, Bowling Green 1 | Ed DiFiore, St. Edward | Andy Franck, St. Edward | ||||||||
| 1998 | Shaker Hts. 4, Padua 1 | Abe Kinkopf, Shaker Heights | Scott Graham, Shaker Heights | ||||||||
| 1999 | St. Ignatius 2, St. Edward 1 | Rob McDonnell, St. Ignatius | Mike Downey, St. Ignatius | ||||||||
| 2000 | Padua 7, Shaker Hts. 3 | Carson Strang, Shaker Heights | Justin Wolf, Padua | ||||||||
| 2001 | Bowling Green 3, Gilmour Academy 2 | Kevin Rawlik, Bowling Green | Eric Curtiss, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 2002 | Bowling Green 6, Trinity 1 | Steve Culbertson, Bowling Green | Dan Marcson, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 2003 | Bowling Green 6, Shaker Hts. 1 | Kevin Rawlik, Bowling Green | Dan Marcson, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 2004 | Shaker Hts. 3, Bowling Green 2 | Pat Chevallier, Shaker Heights | Alex Antolino, Shaker Heights | ||||||||
| 2005 | Trinity 5, Bowling Green 0 | Richard Tropf, Trinity | Michael Stout, Trinity | ||||||||
| 2006 | Bowling Green 5, Shaker Hts. 0 | Rob Yohe, Bowling Green | Jeremy Cross, Bowling Green | ||||||||
| 2007 | St. Ignatius 3, Bowling Green 0 | Jay Mazzarella, St. Ignatius | Ed Zdolshek, St. Ignatius | ||||||||
| 2008 | St. Ignatius 5, Bowling Green 1 | Sam Nader, St. Ignatius | Ed Zdolshek, St. Ignatius | ||||||||
| 2009 | Walsh Jesuit 3, Bowling Green 0 | Nate Myeroff, Walsh Jesuit | Zach Gaul, Walsh Jesuit | ||||||||