| Plain Dealer Winter All-Stars - Ice Hockey | ||||||||
| 1995 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | 1996 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | |||||||
| Player | School | Position | Grade | Player | School | Position | Grade | |
| Drew Carleton | University School | F | Jr. | Drew Carleton | University School | F | Sr. | |
| Ryan Czech | Padua | F | Jr. | Rae Metz | Kent Roosevelt | F | Sr. | |
| Ben Simon | Shaker Hts. | F | Jr. | Paul Neundorfer | Cleveland Hts. | F | Sr. | |
| Mike Bujdos | St. Edward | D | Jr. | Mike Bujdos | St. Edward | D | Sr. | |
| Nate Heckman | Padua | D | Sr. | Matt Butler | St. Edward | D | Sr. | |
| Ben Friedell | Shaker Hts. | G | Soph. | Paul Chase | St. Ignatius | G | Sr. | |
| Player of the Year - Ben Simon, Shaker Hts. | Player of the Year - Drew Carleton, University School | |||||||
| Coach of the Year - Doug Hauser, Padua | Coach of the Year - Doug Hauser, Padua | |||||||
| 1997 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | 1998 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | |||||||
| Player | School | Position | Grade | Player | School | Position | Grade | |
| Anthony Balamenti | Trinity | F | Sr. | Ed DiFiore | St. Edward | F | Sr. | |
| Evan Schwartz | Shaker Hts. | F | Jr. | Todd Ekstrand | Padua | F | Sr. | |
| Matt Taylor | Padua | F | Sr. | Evan Schwartz | Shaker Hts. | F | Sr. | |
| Brian Bost | Padua | D | Sr. | Nick Raso | Padua | D | Sr. | |
| Bryan Kuchta | Padua | D | Soph. | Tyler Friedman | Shaker Hts. | D | Jr. | |
| Dan Carbol | Trinity | G | Sr. | Brian Batzel | Valley Forge | G | Sr. | |
| Player of the Year - Anthony Balamenti, Trinity | Player of the Year - Evan Schwartz, Shaker Hts. | |||||||
| Coach of the Year - John Malloy, Rocky River | Coach of the Year - Bob Whidden, St. Edward | |||||||
| 1999 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | 2000 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | |||||||
| Player | School | Position | Grade | Player | School | Position | Grade | |
| Chris Bilyk | University School | F | Sr. | Rashaun Ewing | Shaker Hts. | F | Sr. | |
| Rashaun Ewing | Shaker Hts. | F | Jr. | Jim Gilbride | Padua | F | Sr. | |
| David Neundorfer | University School | F | Sr. | Matt Zeman | St. Ignatius | F | Sr. | |
| Joe Branco | Padua | D | Sr. | Tom Muranko | Padua | D | Sr. | |
| Shane Print | University School | D | Sr. | Mike Perrin | Shaker Hts. | D | Sr. | |
| Scott Graham | Shaker Hts. | G | Sr. | Derek Classen | University School | G | Sr. | |
| Player of the Year - David Neundorfer, University School | Player of the Year - Rashaun Ewing, Shaker Hts. | |||||||
| Coach of the Year - Bill Beard, University School | Coach of the Year - Richard Homovec, Euclid | |||||||
| 2001 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | 2002 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | |||||||
| Player | School | Position | Grade | Player | School | Position | Grade | |
| Josh Coyle | Padua | F | Jr. | Johnny Dingle | Shaker Hts. | F | Sr. | |
| Pat Neundorfer | University School | F | Jr. | Pat Neundorfer | University School | F | Sr. | |
| Carson Strang | Shaker Hts. | F | Sr. | Jason O'Bannon | St. Edward | F | Jr. | |
| Brian Kolesar | Padua | D | Sr. | Chris Essey | Padua | D | Sr. | |
| Matt Wallace | Shaker Hts. | D | Jr. | Matt Wallace | Shaker Hts. | D | Sr. | |
| Justin Wolf | Padua | G | Sr. | Dan Koletsky | Shaker Hts. | G | Jr. | |
| Player of the Year - Carson Strang, Shaker Hts. | Player of the Year - Patrick Neundorfer, University School | |||||||
| Coach of the Year - Mike Bartley, Shaker Hts. | Coach of the Year - Bob Whidden, St. Edward | |||||||
| 2003 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | 2004 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | |||||||
| Player | School | Position | Grade | Player | School | Position | Grade | |
| Curt Kassigkeit | University School | F | Sr. | David Bruder | St. Edward | F | Sr. | |
| Eric Sefchik | St. Edward | F | Sr. | Larry Germovsek | University School | F | Sr. | |
| Elliot Taxman | University School | F | Jr. | Elliot Taxman | University School | F | Sr. | |
| Kerry Cebult | University School | D | Sr. | Jonathan Kestner | University School | D | Sr. | |
| Matt Musick | St. Edward | D | Jr. | Matt Musick | St. Edward | D | Sr. | |
| Dan Koletsky | Shaker Hts. | G | Sr. | Bobby Waltzer | Padua | G | Jr. | |
| Player of the Year - Kerry Cebul, University School | Player of the Year - Elliot Taxman, University School | |||||||
| Coach of the Year - Bill Beard, University School | Coach of the Year - Bob Whidden, St. Edward | |||||||
| 2005 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | 2006 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | |||||||
| Player | School | Position | Grade | Player | School | Position | Grade | |
| Christian Long | St. Edward | F | Soph. | Matt Feda | Padua | F | Sr. | |
| Jeff Musser | Shaker Hts. | F | Sr. | Bill Fetsko | Lake Catholic | F | Sr. | |
| J.J. Plutt | Lake Catholic | F | Sr. | T.J. Murphy | North Olmsted | F | Sr. | |
| Jake Coyle | Padua | D | Sr. | Brandon Hemmelgarn | Shaker Hts. | D | Sr. | |
| Chris Smith | St. Edward | D | Jr. | Matt Ryder | University School | D | Sr. | |
| Alex Antolino | Shaker Hts. | G | Sr. | Ken Kucinski | Lake Catholic | G | Sr. | |
| Player of the Year - J.J. Plutt, Lake Catholic | Player of the Year - Bill Fetsko, Lake Catholic | |||||||
| Coach of the Year - Bob Whidden, St. Edward | Coach of the Year - Tony Prpic, Lake Catholic | |||||||
| 2007 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | 2008 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | |||||||
| Player | School | Position | Grade | Player | School | Position | Grade | |
| Richie Baker | Elyria Catholic | F | Jr. | Richie Baker | Elyria Catholic | F | Sr. | |
| Justin Phenney | Padua | F | Sr. | Vinny Buttita | St. Edward | F | Sr. | |
| Gabe Taxman | University School | F | Sr. | Chad Murphy | North Olmsted | F | Jr. | |
| Ricky Chipka | St. Edward | D | Sr. | Alex Barrett | University School | D | Jr. | |
| Mike Sotak | University School | D | Soph. | Alex Hanko | St. Edward | D | Sr. | |
| Brian Tighe | University School | G | Sr. | Robbie Ginsburg | St. Edward | G | Sr. | |
| Player of the Year - Gabe Taxman, University School | Player of the Year - Richie Baker, Elyria Catholic | |||||||
| Coach of the Year - Dave Phiel, Elyria Catholic | Coach of the Year - Rob Whidden, St. Edward | |||||||
| 2009 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | 2010 Plain Dealer All-Star Hockey Team | |||||||
| Player | School | Position | Grade | Player | School | Position | Grade | |
| Ross Kivett | St. Edward | F | Jr. | Ross Kivett | St. Edward | F | Sr. | |
| Chad Murphy | North Olmsted | F | Sr. | Patrick Spellacy | St. Ignatius | F | Soph. | |
| Pat Shedlock | University School | F | Sr. | Matt Wipper | University School | F | Soph. | |
| Bill Andreski | Strongsville | D | Sr. | Nate Myeroff | Walsh Jesuit | D | Jr. | |
| Kevin Ryder | University School | D | Sr. | Sam Nader | St. Ignatius | D | Sr. | |
| Ed Zdolshek | St. Ignatius | G | Sr. | Jamie Regan | University School | G | Sr. | |
| Player of the Year - Pat Shedlock, University School | Player of the Year - Sam Nader, St. Ignatius | |||||||
| Coach of the Year - Bill Beard, University School | Coach of the Year - Patrick O'Rourke, St. Ignatius | |||||||