| Date |
Round |
Final Score |
Goal Scorer |
Time |
| March 22, 1980 |
Semi-Final |
Toledo Central Catholic 4 |
Shaker Heights 3 |
Mark McAlear |
3:56 |
| March 21, 1981 |
Semi-Final |
Shaker Heights 4 |
Sylvania Northview 3 |
Mark Spring |
14:40 |
| March 11, 1989 |
Semi-Final |
Trinity 5 |
Bowling Green 4 |
Scott Kalen |
5:16 |
| March 5, 1994 |
Semi-Final |
Findlay 5 |
Cleveland Heights 4 |
Rick Lance |
7:22 |
| March 14, 2009 |
Semi-Final |
University School 4 |
St. Edward 3 |
Andy Gerow |
9:07 |
| March 21, 1982 |
Final |
Kent Roosevelt 4 |
Sylvania Northview 3 |
Randy Madey |
5:59 |
| March 8, 1987 |
Final |
Cleveland Heights 4 |
St. Edward 3 |
Andy Shriver |
15:42 |
| March 9, 1992 |
Final |
St. Edward 1 |
Bowling Green 0 |
Joe Mazzone |
10:58 |
| March 6, 1994 |
Final |
St. Edward 4 |
Findlay 3 |
Seth Andregg |
1:11 |
| March 8, 1998 |
Final |
Bowling Green 5 |
Shaker Heights 4 |
Rob Ellis |
0:39 |
| March 12, 2006 |
Final |
Padua 6 |
Sylvania Northview 5 |
Ryan Saunders |
2:05 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
