| OHSAA All-Time Final Four Tournament Results | |||||
| Year | Round | Winning Team - Coach - Record | Score | Losing Team - Coach - Record | Score |
| 1978 | Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Ron Lozon (19-7) | 7 | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (20-6) | 4 |
| Semi-Finals | Findlay - Ted Sator (22-6) | 10 | Bay Village - Tom Williams (15-8-1) | 1 | |
| Finals | Findlay - Ted Sator (23-6) | 8 | Bowling Green - Ron Lozon (19-8) | 7 | |
| 1979 | Semi-Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (27-0-1) | 8 | Findlay - Mike Root (18-5-1) | 4 |
| Semi-Finals | Centerville - Keith Harring (20-5) | 8 | Rocky River - Pat Fahey (21-7) | 2 | |
| Finals | Centerville - Keith Harring (21-5) | 6 | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (27-1-1) | 3 | |
| 1980 | Semi-Finals | Toledo Central Catholic - Toby Pizza (21-5-1) | 4 | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (24-4) | 3 (ot) |
| Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Tom Olsen (21-5) | 4 | Cleveland Heights - Bill Reed (20-7) | 3 | |
| Finals | Bowling Green - Tom Olsen (22-5) | 5 | Toledo Central Catholic - Toby Pizza (21-6-1) | 2 | |
| 1981 | Semi-Finals | Kent Roosevelt - Bernie Hovey (26-2) | 7 | Toledo St. John's - Cosimo Figliomeni (12-10-1) | 3 |
| Semi-Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (28-0) | 4 | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (23-5) | 3 (2 ot) | |
| Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (29-0) | 10 | Kent Roosevelt - Bernie Hovey (26-3) | 4 | |
| 1982 | Semi-Finals | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (25-3-1) | 6 | North Olmsted - Ian Cushenan (25-5) | 3 |
| Semi-Finals | Kent Roosevelt - Bernie Hovey (27-2-1) | 8 | Sylvania Southview - Tim Fero (8-11-1) | 2 | |
| Finals | Kent Roosevelt - Bernie Hovey (28-2-1) | 4 | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (25-4-1) | 3 (ot) | |
| 1983 | Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Randy Sokoll (23-1-1) | 7 | Padua - Larry Pizon (21-6) | 3 |
| Semi-Finals | Findlay - Mike Root (24-2) | 3 | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (17-9-1) | 1 | |
| Finals | Findlay - Mike Root (25-2) | 6 | Bowling Green - Randy Sokoll (23-2-1) | 4 | |
| 1984 | Semi-Finals | Toledo Whitmer - Greg Jablonski (26-1-1) | 2 | North Olmsted - Ian Cushenan (26-4) | 1 |
| Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Randy Sokoll (29-1) | 4 | Cleveland Heights - John Malloy (25-3-1) | 3 | |
| Finals | Bowling Green - Randy Sokoll (30-1) | 10 | Toledo Whitmer - Greg Jablonski (26-2-1) | 3 | |
| 1985 | Semi-Finals | North Olmsted - Ron Ward (23-8) | 4 | Toledo St. Francis - Greg Fox (16-11-1) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (21-5-1) | 5 | Toledo St. John's - Cosimo Figliomeni (21-6-2) | 2 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (22-5-1) | 1 | North Olmsted - Ron Ward (23-9) | 0 | |
| 1986 | Semi-Finals | Cleveland Heights - John Malloy (30-0) | 3 | Toledo St. John's - Cosimo Figliomeni (16-10-1) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (24-5-1) | 5 | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (20-5-4) | 3 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (25-5-1) | 6 | Cleveland Heights - John Malloy (30-1) | 5 | |
| 1987 | Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (25-5) | 5 | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (27-4-1) | 3 |
| Semi-Finals | Cleveland Heights - John Malloy (28-2) | 4 | Bowling Green - Randy Sokoll (20-10-2) | 1 | |
| Finals | Cleveland Heights - John Malloy (29-2) | 4 | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (25-6) | 3 (2 ot) | |
| 1988 | Semi-Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (29-2) | 4 | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (26-7-1) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | Toledo St. Francis - Mark Hamilton (20-12-1) | 2 | Toledo St. John's - Cosimo Figliomeni (18-10-1) | 1 | |
| Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (30-2) | 4 | Toledo St. Francis - Mark Hamilton (20-13-1) | 2 | |
| 1989 | Semi-Finals | Trinity - Mark Ferfolia (17-15) | 4 | Bowling Green - Randy Sokoll (24-7) | 3 (ot) |
| Semi-Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (27-4-1) | 11 | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (19-8-2) | 2 | |
| Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (28-4-1) | 5 | Trinity - Mark Ferfolia (17-16) | 1 | |
| 1990 | Semi-Finals | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (20-10-1) | 5 | Unviersity School - Gary Geldart (21-5-1) | 4 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (29-1) | 6 | Toldeo St. John's - Bob Zion (18-11-1) | 1 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (30-1) | 4 | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (20-11-1) | 1 | |
| 1991 | Semi-Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (26-6) | 8 | Toldeo St. John's - Bob Zion (21-8-2) | 4 |
| Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (27-3) | 2 | Cleveland Heights - John Malloy (21-9) | 1 | |
| Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (28-3) | 2 | Padua - Doug Hauser (26-7) | 1 | |
| 1992 | Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (25-3) | 4 | Trinity - Mark Ferfolia (12-17) | 1 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (17-10-2) | 6 | Toledo St. Francis - Mark Hamilton (13-15) | 2 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (18-10-2) | 1 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (25-4) | 0 (2 ot) | |
| 1993 | Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (24-3-1) | 2 | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (24-7-1) | 1 |
| Semi-Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (25-4-1) | 3 | Toledo St. John's - Mike Mankowski (16-14-1) | 0 | |
| Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (26-4-1) | 2 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (24-4-1) | 1 | |
| 1994 | Semi-Finals | Findlay - Mike Root (22-5) | 5 | Cleveland Heights - John Malloy (12-15) | 4 (ot) |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (28-2-1) | 11 | Toledo St. John's - Mike Mankowski (13-19) | 0 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (29-2-1) | 4 | Findlay - Mike Root (22-6) | 3 (ot) | |
| 1995 | Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (22-5) | 3 | St. Ignatius - Gil Ratcliff (13-12-2) | 1 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (20-5-5) | 7 | Toledo St. Francis - Mark Hamilton (22-6-1) | 0 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (21-5-5) | 2 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (22-6) | 1 | |
| 1996 | Semi-Finals | Bolwing Green - Dan DeWitt (23-5-1) | 3 | St. Ignatius - Mike Bauman (16-12-4) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (20-5-3) | 11 | Centerville - Tim Evans (22-9-2) | 1 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (21-5-3) | 3 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (23-6-1) | 1 | |
| 1997 | Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (29-5-1) | 7 | St. Ignatius - Mike Bauman (17-15) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (24-3-1) | 4 | Centerville - Tim Evans (19-12-1) | 1 | |
| Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (25-3-1) | 2 | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (29-6-1) | 1 | |
| 1998 | Semi-Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (21-6-2) | 2 | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (29-6) | 0 |
| Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (21-7-1) | 3 | Toledo St. John's - Mike Mankowski (26-6) | 2 | |
| Finals | Bowling Green Dan DeWitt (22-7-1) | 5 | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (21-7-2) | 4 (ot) | |
| 1999 | Semi-Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (17-10-1) | 6 | Unviersity School - Bill Beard (28-4) | 0 |
| Semi-Finals | Toledo St. John's - Mike Mankowski (25-5-1) | 2 | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (26-3-1) | 1 | |
| Finals | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (18-10-1) | Forfeit | Toledo St. John's - Mike Mankowski (25-6-1) | ||
| 2000 | Semi-Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (27-6-1) | 6 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (18-11-1) | 1 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Ignatius - Scott Pick (28-6-2) | 5 | Toledo St. John's - Mike Mankowski (24-8) | 0 | |
| Finals | St. Ignatius - Scott Pick (29-6-2) | 4 | Padua - Doug Hauser (27-7-1) | 1 | |
| 2001 | Semi-Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (33-3) | 3 | Toldeo St. John's - Mike Mankowski (23-10) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (20-9-3) | 4 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (21-8) | 2 | |
| Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (21-9-3) | 3 | Padua - Doug Hauser (33-4) | 1 | |
| 2002 | Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (22-13-1) | 1 | Findlay - Mike Root (18-10-1) | 0 |
| Semi-Finals | University School - Bill Beard (26-11-4) | 4 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (27-4-1) | 0 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (23-13-1) | 5 | University School - Bill Beard (26-12-4) | 3 | |
| 2003 | Semi-Finals | University School - Bill Beard (24-11-4) | 6 | Thomas Worthington - Adam Smith (30-7) | 1 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (34-7-2) | 5 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (29-2) | 3 | |
| Finals | University School - Bill Beard (25-11-4) | 2 | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (34-8-2) | 1 | |
| 2004 | Semi-Finals | University School - Bill Beard (21-15-2) | 4 | Bowling Green - Dan DeWitt (27-2-1) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (31-8-2) | 5 | Oxford Talawanda - Scott Shantery (19-9-2) | 0 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (32-8-2) | 8 | Unviversity School - Bill Beard (21-16-2) | 0 | |
| 2005 | Semi-Finals | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (24-7) | 6 | Toledo St. Francis - Mike Greeder (22-8-1) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (28-10-1) | 5 | Cincinnati Moeller - Mike Reeder (27-7-2) | 0 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Bob Whidden (29-10-1) | 2 | Shaker Heights - Mike Bartley (24-8) | 0 | |
| 2006 | Semi-Finals | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (30-4-2) | 2 | University School - Bill Beard (19-13-2) | 1 |
| Semi-Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser - (23-10-3) | 7 | Upper Arlington - Jay Graham (27-9-1) | 4 | |
| Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (24-10-3) | 6 | Sylvania Northview - Jim Cooper (31-4-2) | 5 (ot) | |
| 2007 | Semi-Finals | Toledo St. John's - Mike Hayes (28-7-3) | 5 | University School - Bill Beard (22-13-3) | 3 |
| Semi-Finals | Padua - Doug Hauser (28-9-2) | 3 | Upper Arlington - Jay Graham (25-14-4) | 2 | |
| Finals | Toledo St. John's - Mike Hayes (29-7-3) | 6 | Padua - Doug Hauser (28-10-2) | 4 | |
| 2008 | Semi-Finals | St. Edward - Rob Whidden (28-11-3) | 4 | Toledo St. Francis - Brian Kinsella (19-14-3) | 2 |
| Semi-Finals | Gilmour Academy - John Malloy (23-17-1) | 4 | St. Xavier - Adam Tramonte (16-13-5) | 2 | |
| Finals | St. Edward - Rob Whidden (29-11-3) | 3 | Gilmour Academy - John Mally (23-18-1) | 1 | |
| 2009 | Semi-Finals | University School - Bill Beard (30-6-3) | 4 | St. Edward - Rob Whidden (28-6-5) | 3 (2 ot) |
| Semi-Finals | Toledo St. John's - Markus Rasmus (23-9-4) | 7 | Centerville - Adam Frank (20-10-2) | 0 | |
| Finals | University School - Bill Beard (31-6-3) | 3 | Toledo St. John's - Markus Rasmus (23-10-4) | 0 | |
| 2010 | Semi-Finals | St. Ignatius - Patrick O'Rourke (30-7-3) | 5 | University School - Bill Beard (22-11-2) | 1 |
| Semi-Finals | Sylvania Northview - Mike Jones (21-8-3) | 4 | Dublin Coffman - (30-8-2) | 0 | |
| Finals | St. Ignatius - Patrick O'Rourke (31-7-3) | 4 | Sylvania Northview - Mike Jones (21-9-3) | 1 | |