| All-Scholastic Coach of the Year | ||
| Year | Coach | School |
| 1975 | Jack Beilbelhausen | Padua |
| 1976 | Bill Reed | Cleveland Heights |
| 1977 | Mike Bartley | Shaker Heights |
| 1978 | Bill Needam | Lakewood |
| 1979 | Dick Homovec | Euclid |
| 1980 | Dick Homovec | Euclid |
| 1981 | Bernie Hovey | Kent Roosevelt |
| 1982 | Bernie Hovey | Kent Roosevelt |
| 1983 | John Malloy | Cleveland Heights |
| 1984 | ||
| 1985 | John Malloy | Cleveland Heights |
| 1986 | John Malloy | Cleveland Heights |
| 1987 | John Malloy | Cleveland Heights |
| 1988 | Doug Hauser | Padua |
| 1989 | Gary Geldart | University School |
| 1990 | Stan Budzick | Brooklyn |
| 1991 | Stan Budzick | Brooklyn |
| 1992 | Dave Janik | Rocky River |
| 1993 | Mike Bartley | Shaker Heights |
| 1994 | Bob Whidden | St. Edward |
| 1995 | Doug Hauser | Padua |
| 1996 | Doug Hauser | Padua |
| 1997 | John Malloy | Rocky River |
| 1998 | Bob Whidden | St. Edward |
| 1999 | Bill Beard | University School |