| BARON CUP II CHAMPIONSHIP GAME RESULTS | |||||
| Year | Champion | Coach | Score | Winning Goal | Runner-Up |
| 1986 | Euclid | Gary Geldart | 5 - 4 | Paul Borthwick | Brooklyn |
| 1987 | St. Ignatius | Phil Ryder | 4 - 2 | Mike Sheehan | Garfield Heights |
| 1988 | St. Ignatius | Phil Ryder | 4 - 2 | Rick Simon | Bay Village |
| 1989 | Brooklyn | Stan Budzik | 6 - 1 | Lakewood | |
| 1990 | Bay Village | Tom Williams | 2 - 1 (ot) | Andy Klassen | Lakewood |
| 1991 | Rocky River | Dave Janik | 4 - 3 | Dave Farrall | Brooklyn |
| 1992 | Rocky River | Dave Janik | 5 - 3 | Dave Farrall | Mentor |
| 1993 | Euclid | Forest Dixon | 4 - 3 (ot) | Ray Morris | Garfield Heights |
| 1994 | Bay Village | Joe Kilburg | 3 - 1 | Matt Bauer | Lakewood |
| 1995 | Mentor | Jack Smeltz | 2 - 1 | Joe Sherman | North Olmsted |
| 1996 | Kent Roosevelt | Rae Metz | 3 - 1 | Rae Metz | Olmsted Falls |
| 1997 | Rocky River | John Malloy | 4 - 1 | Paul Ranalli | Parma |
| 1998 | Normandy | Jim Jackson | 6 - 1 | Kent Roosevelt | |
| 1999 | Normandy | Jim Jackson | 5 - 2 | Pat Monnolly | Brooklyn |
| 2000 | Hudson | Steve Shaffer | 6 - 3 | Euclid | |
| 2002 | Western Reserve | Brand Closen | 3 - 1 | Kyle Closen | Mayfield |
| 2003 | Bay Village | Terry Chadwick | 4 - 2 | Derek Lindsay | Solon |
| 2004 | Bay Village | Terry Chadwick | 3 - 1 | Derek Lindsay | Kent Roosevelt |
| 2005 | Amherst Steele | Steve Morris | 2 - 1 | Eric Polansky | Orange |
| 2006 | Orange | Kyle Koennecke | 5 - 0 | Bryan Clark | Parma |
| 2007 | Kent Roosevelt | Ben Barlow | 5 - 3 | Bobby Bair | Walsh Jesuit |
| 2008 | Brecksville | Dan Holden | 4 - 3 (ot) | Tony O'Neil | Rocky River |
| 2009 | Rocky River | Chris Cogan | 2 - 1 (ot) | Matt Garibaldi | Western Reserve |
| 2010 | Rocky River | Chris Cogan | 5 - 4 | Kyle Lamb | Kenston |